T20 World Cup 2024: Umpiring error cost match to Bangladesh; Controversy erupts - Cricket Winner

Cricket fans witnessed a dramatic and contentious moment during Bangladesh’s all-important T20 World Cup 2024 clash against South Africa in New York. This rare outburst came from fans after a controversial umpiring decision that had significant implications on the match’s outcome.

Background of the Match

The stakes were high as Bangladesh and South Africa faced off in a crucial match. South Africa, aiming to secure their spot in the Super Eight, opted to bat first and set a modest target of 114 runs. Despite the low total, Bangladesh’s strategy was to maintain pressure through disciplined bowling and cautious batting.

See Also: T20 World Cup 2024: What happens to Pakistan if they lose against Canada?

The Controversial Decision

The incident occurred in the 17th over of Bangladesh’s innings, with Ottneil Baartman bowling to Mahmudullah. As Baartman delivered a full ball on the stumps, Mahmudullah missed the flick, and the ball hit his pad before racing to the boundary. Umpire Sam Nogajski raised his finger for an LBW, much to the dismay of Mahmudullah and the Bangladesh team.

Najmul Hossain Shanto’s Reaction

Shanto, who had been dismissed earlier, was visibly agitated in the dugout. Known for his composed nature, his visible frustration and anger highlighted the gravity of the umpire’s decision.

Technical Analysis of the LBW Decision

The umpire’s call was pivotal. The slow-motion replay showed the ball missing the leg stump, overturning the initial LBW decision. However, the boundary resulting from the deflection was not counted, as the ball was deemed dead post the umpire’s verdict. This technicality sparked widespread debate about the fairness and accuracy of such rulings.

Implications of the Decision

The immediate impact of the decision was profound. The four leg-byes, which were not added to Bangladesh’s total due to the dead ball ruling, could have significantly influenced the match’s outcome. Ultimately, Bangladesh lost by four runs, making the missed runs a critical talking point.

Fan Reactions

Fans reacted with a mix of outrage and disbelief. Social media platforms were abuzz with criticism of the umpiring standards and calls for better use of technology.

Feel for Bangladesh…!!!! 🥺

– Bangladesh at one point needed 26 runs of 23 balls and Haridoy given out on by the umpires on this delivery but ball was missing and due to rule the 4 runs was not given & they lost by 4 runs. pic.twitter.com/GotS5zYdb3

— Tanuj Singh (@ImTanujSingh) June 10, 2024

An umpire horror costs Bangladesh FOUR runs in this hell of a pitch when they needed 26/23. Umpires aren't humans, they're vultures.

— arfan (@Im__Arfan) June 10, 2024

In crucial moments of Bangladesh's chase

17th over – LBW decision reviewed and overturned. But Bangladesh miss the 4 leg byes as it is a dead ball once umpire raises the finger.

18th over – LBW decision reviewed. But Towrid Hridoy out as it is umpires call.#BANvSA #T20WC

— Kausthub Gudipati (@kaustats) June 10, 2024

At 16.2, There was a Clear Not Out which went for Boundary but due to the RULE, that was called dead balla nd 4 runs weren't counted..

In the End, Bangladesh Lost the Match by exactly "4 RUNS" only!

Bangladesh suffers a defeat because of Umpires Error.. @ICC dei FIX it#BanvsSA pic.twitter.com/FF8IzA6tMr

— Karthick Shivaraman (Imagine NO Blue tick Here) (@iskarthi_) June 10, 2024

Mahmudullah was wrongly given out LBW, and ball went for 4 leg byes. The decision was reversed on DRS but Bangladesh didn't get the 4 runs as ball is dead once batter is given out. And South Africa won by exactly 4 runs. Tragic indeed 🇧🇩💔💔#tapmad #HojaoADFree #T20WorldCup pic.twitter.com/A2KmVVLYB0

— Farid Khan (@_FaridKhan) June 10, 2024